Connect with us

Legal Affairs

Adeleke vs Oyetola: How Supreme Court ruling will shape Tinubu, Obi and Atiku’s fate

Published

on

The Supreme Court will today at 2.00 pm deliver judgment in the disputed July 16, 2022 governorship election in Osun State between incumbent Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) governor, Senator Ademola Adeleke, and All Progressives Party (APC) contender, Mr. Adegboyega Oyetola.

The apex court fixed the period for the judgment after taking arguments from parties on an appeal filed by Oyetola and APC, with Adeleke, PDP and INEC as respondents.

Recall that Oyetola had brought a petition against the declaration of incumbent Osun State Governor Ademola Adeleke as winner of the governorship election. While the tribunal in a split two-to-one decision held that Oyetola won majority of the lawful votes cast in the election, Adeleke and INEC challenged the tribunal’s decision, saying that it erred in law.

Today’s decision by the apex court may set the tone for the potential outcome of the petitIons filed by several political parties and their candidates at the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT). Notably, Mr. Peter Obi of Labour Party (LP) and Alhaji Atiku Abubakar of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) are challenging the declaration of Senator Bola Tinubu of All Progressives Congress (APC) as winner of the February 25, 2023 presidential election.

The Court of Appeal had unanimously held that the Osun State Tribunal erred in law when it decided that there was over-voting during the election, saying the claim only relied on the evidence by Oyetola and the APC and as such, doesn’t prove their case.

The court faulted Oyetola and APC for relying only on the data from the back-end server and failing to look at the voters’ register which forms the foundation of the whole electoral process. It held that as such, the respondents could not sustain their allegation of over-voting. The position of the apex court today on the subject will lay the precedent for lower courts to follow.

READ ALSO:  Boko Haram: Relatives of kidnapped girls reject, persecute them on homecoming

Oyetola had appealed to the apex court in the lawsuit marked as SC/CV/510/2023. He urged the apex court to upturn the decision of the Court of Appeal. In the appeal brought on Oyetola’s behalf by his Lead Counsel, Prince Lateef Fagbemi SAN, the appellant formulated eight issues among which is “Whether the court below was right in declaring as nullity the judgment of the Tribunal delivered on 27th January 2023 notwithstanding the earlier resolution of the same Court that Section 294(1) and (2) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is inapplicable to a Tribunal.”

He urged the apex court to determine whether the appellate court was right “in declaring as nullity the judgment of the tribunal delivered on January 27 notwithstanding the earlier resolution of the same court that Section 294(1) of the Constitution is inapplicable to a tribunal”.

He also urged the court to decide whether the lower court was right in concluding that the appellants did not prove the allegation of over-voting in favour of Adeleke.

But INEC had through its Lead Counsel, Prof. Paul Ananaba SAN filed an unprecedented 34 grounds of appeal against the decision of the tribunal, leading to a reversal by the appellate court.

The commission, in a certified copy of the Cross Appeal obtained filed on its behalf by Ananaba, urged the apex court “to allow this Cross-Appeal, and also set aside the decision of the Tribunal delivered on 27th January 2023 on the ground that the judgment of the Honourable Tribunal delivered on 27th January 2023 by Hon. Justice T. A. Kume and signed by Rabi Bashir (CM) is not in compliance with the provisions of section 294(2) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended) and amounts to a nullity.

READ ALSO:  Buhari inaugurates National Oil and Gas Excellence Centre in Lagos

“We further urge your Lordships to reject the said Exhibits RC1, RC2, BVR, PUBL 1-3 and CER in evidence and expunge them from the record of the Honourable Tribunal.”

INEC distilled two issues for the determination of the Supreme Court, namely “Whether the learned Justices of the Court of Appeal were right in holding that the judgment of the Osun State Governorship Election Tribunal delivered on 27th January 2023 by Hon. Justice T. A. Kume and signed by Rabi Bashir (Chief Magistrate) on the same page is not a nullity (Distilled from Ground 1 of the Notice of Appeal).”

The commission also urged the Supreme Court to determine whether the learned Justices of the Court of Appeal were right “in upholding the decision of the Tribunal not to have rejected in evidence Exhibits RC1, RC2 and BVR, Exhibits SCH1, SCH2, SCH3 and Exhibit PUBL 1-3 tendered by the 1st and 2nd Cross-Respondents (Distilled from Ground 2 of the Notice of Appeal

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Legal Affairs

Outrage as Court Grants Bail to Suspects in Wedding Guest Killings in Plateau

Published

on

Relatives of the 13 wedding guests killed in Plateau State have condemned the State High Court’s decision to release 20 suspects on bail.

The victims were brutally murdered on June 12, 2025, when a mob attacked their bus in Mangun district, Mangu Local Government Area.

They were traveling from Kaduna State to attend a wedding in Qua’an Pan LGA before tragedy struck.

According to reports, the group lost their way and entered a volatile community already shaken by recent terrorist activity.

Local youths allegedly mistook them for bandits and launched a deadly assault, leaving 13 people dead on the spot.

Following the killings, security operatives arrested 21 suspects.

In an earlier court sitting, 20 of them were remanded at the Jos Correctional Center while investigations continued.

However, on Wednesday, August 20, Justice Nafisa Lawal Musa granted bail after a motion filed by defence counsel, Garba Pwul (SAN).

This ruling has triggered outrage among the families of the victims, who insist the development is a slap in the face of justice.

Mallam Abdullahi Tahir Balami, a relative of one of the deceased, condemned the court’s action.

Speaking to reporters, he described the ruling as suspicious and raised concerns about possible foul play.

“With this development, we are now questioning the commitment of the Plateau State government to justice,” Balami said.

“It is saddening that suspects in a multiple homicide case can be released on bail.”

Another relative, Mallam Ubale Anguwar Dantsoho, who lost several family members, also expressed anger.

He described the decision as shocking and warned that justice may never be served.

READ ALSO:  Ekiti State Govt Commences Phase One of Airport Project

“How can suspects in a murder case be granted bail?” he asked. “It shows that our system is failing us.”

Maryam Usman, widow of the driver killed in the massacre, expressed her heartbreak.

She said she struggled to understand why suspects linked to such a crime would be freed.

“What kind of court is this?” she asked in despair. “Instead of justice, the court dashed our hopes. We no longer believe justice will come.”

Her words echoed the feelings of many families now convinced that the judiciary has abandoned them.

Human rights activists are also calling for urgent intervention from both the state and federal governments to ensure accountability.

The Plateau killings have become one of the most disturbing tragedies in recent months.

The case now highlights the growing tension between grieving families and a judicial system accused of ignoring victims.

Continue Reading

Legal Affairs

Court upholds Zamfara govt’s seizure of 40 vehicles from Matawalle

Published

on

Zamfara State Governor, Ambassador Bello Matawalle

The Court of Appeal in Sokoto has upheld the Federal High Court’s decision dismissing former Zamfara State Governor Bello Matawalle’s challenge over the confiscation of over 40 official vehicles seized from his residence after he left office in 2023.

Delivering its unanimous verdict on August 8, 2025, a three-member panel led by Justice A.M. Talba ruled that Matawalle failed to provide credible evidence proving personal ownership of the vehicles.

The court emphasized that the vehicles were government property, not private assets, and rejected his claim that the seizure violated his fundamental property rights.

According to Zamfara State Governor Dauda Lawal’s spokesman, Sulaiman Idris, the vehicles were recovered in June 2023 after Matawalle and his deputy ignored a five-day ultimatum to return them.

Following their refusal, the state government sought and obtained a court order, enabling police operatives to raid Matawalle’s residence and recover the vehicles.

Initially, Matawalle secured an interim ruling from the Federal High Court in Gusau for the vehicles to be returned to him.

He also filed a separate suit claiming the confiscation breached his fundamental rights.

However, the case was transferred to the Sokoto division of the Federal High Court, which dismissed his claims in December 2023, affirming that the vehicles remained state property.

Dissatisfied with the lower court’s ruling, Matawalle escalated the matter to the Court of Appeal.

The appellate court, however, upheld the Federal High Court’s decision, affirming that the police acted lawfully in investigating the alleged misappropriation and that the state government followed due process in retrieving the vehicles.

READ ALSO:  Presidency releases compendium of over 50 vessels arrested for illegal oil bunkering — 1

The court concluded that Matawalle’s claims lacked merit and could not shield him from investigation or potential prosecution.

 

Continue Reading

Legal Affairs

Your tenure as LP chairman is over — Court, INEC tell defiant Abure

Published

on

Abure faction of Labour Party insists Supreme Court Labour Party judgment was in Abure's favour

The leadership crisis tearing the Labour Party apart appears to have reached a turning point as the Federal High Court in Abuja, on Friday, struck out Julius Abure’s case against the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), officially affirming that he is no longer the party’s National Chairman.

The court, in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1523/2025, dismissed Abure’s suit due to a lack of jurisdiction, aligning with the Supreme Court’s earlier verdict on April 4, 2025 (Appeal No. SC/CV/56/2025), which voided all prior recognitions of his leadership.

However, while speaking on the judgment, Senator Nenadi Usman, the party’s Interim National Chairman, described the ruling as a clear victory for the rule of law.

“This decision removes every lingering doubt about Abure’s status. The chapter is closed. It’s time to put distractions behind us and rebuild the Labour Party into the disciplined, people-centred movement Nigerians deserve”, she said.

Also, INEC’s counter-affidavit in the case further solidified the court’s position, stressing that Abure’s tenure, along with that of the National Executive Committee, had expired in June 2024.

The commission also argued that the controversial March 27, 2024 “Nnewi National Convention” was invalid as it violated the 1999 Constitution, the Electoral Act 2022, INEC guidelines, and the Labour Party’s own constitution.

Senator Usman commended the electoral commission for its “clarity, courage, and institutional integrity” in presenting the facts and urged party members to “respect the supremacy of the Constitution and the authority of the courts.”

With bye-elections on the horizon and the 2027 general elections in sight, this ruling could mark the end of a year-long factional battle that has plagued the party.

READ ALSO:  Ekiti State Govt Commences Phase One of Airport Project

The focus now shifts to uniting the Labour Party and preparing for the political challenges ahead.

 

Continue Reading

Legal Affairs

NNPC secures landmark court victory against Senator Araraume

Published

on

Senator Araraume

 

On August 8, 2025, the Court of Appeal, sitting in Abuja, upheld NNPC Ltd.’s appeal against the Federal High Court’s April 2023 judgement that annulled Senator Ifeanyi Araraume’s removal as non-executive Chairman of the NNPC Board and awarded him ₦5 billion in damages.

The Court of Appeal’s judgement spares NNPC Ltd a massive financial payout and removes a legal risk that could have invalidated all decisions of the Board since 2021.

The Appeal Court agreed to NNPC Ltd.’s position that the Federal High Court’s earlier decision was delivered in error, noting amongst others, that the claim was statute-barred.

This decision of the Court of Appeal secures governance stability for NNPC Ltd., sets a corporate governance precedent in Nigerian law, and upholds the validity of Board resolutions critical to the oil and gas industry’s investment and policy direction.

 

Continue Reading

Legal Affairs

Ibom Airport Saga: Court discharges Comfort Emmason

Published

on

Comfort Emmanson

An Ikeja Magistrates’ Court on Wednesday cleared Miss Comfort Emmason of all charges related to unruly behavior and assaulting the flight crew aboard an Ibom Air flight from Uyo to Lagos.

Magistrate Olanrewaju Salami struck out the five-count charge following the withdrawal of the case by the police prosecution team.

During the hearing, prosecutor Oluwabunmi Adeitan informed the court of new developments that led to the decision to discontinue the case.

She submitted a formal application for its withdrawal, which the court accepted, effectively bringing the matter to a close.

 

 

 

 

 

Continue Reading

Latest from DDM TV

Latest Updates

The Caricature Called Nigerian Judiciary: I Discovered Forgery After Court Had Already Accepted It <p><span style='color:#808080;font-size:18px;'><i>By Basil Odilim</i></span></p>

VIRAL VIDEO: Moment Yahaya Bello Orders Kogi State House Members to Sit on Floor, Gives Strict Directives

Why Every Nigerian Should Learn Combat Skills — CDS

Police Arrest Fake Doctor as Woman Dies During Abortion

Trump Orders Review of 55 Million US Visa Holders in Mega Crackdown

2027: ADC Coalition Deceiving Nigerians – Baba-Ahmed

Tinubu Secures Fresh $238m Loan from Japan

‘Gate of Hell’ Will Open on Gaza’– Israeli Defence Issues Finally Warning to Hamas

NAFDAC Raises Alarm as Fake Cowbell Milk Floods Nigerian Markets

‘Misplaced Priority’: Peter Obi Blasts FG’s ₦142bn Bus Terminal Project

Subscribe to DDM Newsletter for Latest News

Trending

Copyright © 2023 -2024 Diaspora Digital Media (DDM) www.diasporadigitalmedia.com. All Rights Reserved . NOTE: All opinion articles published on Diaspora Digital Media are ENTIRELY those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the publishers.

Get Notifications from DDM News Yes please No thanks