Former Manchester City midfielder Dietmar Hamann believes a number of the club’s biggest stars could remain at the Etihad Stadium if the Premier League’s financial sanctions eventually result in relegation to the Championship.
With uncertainty continuing to surround City’s financial case, questions are emerging about how the club would cope with the possible consequences of a severe punishment, particularly whether high-profile players would be willing to sacrifice top-flight football to remain part of the project.
Hamann, who previously represented City, believes a complete departure of the club’s leading players should not necessarily be taken for granted. However, he has warned that the financial implications of relegation could make retaining some of their highest-paid performers extremely difficult.
Speaking to GOAL in association with Lottoland Live Casino, the former Germany international pointed to Juventus as an example of a major European club that managed to retain several legendary players despite suffering one of the most damaging punishments in football history.
Juventus were relegated to Italy’s Serie B in 2006 following their involvement in the Calciopoli scandal, which also resulted in the club being stripped of two Serie A titles.
Despite the embarrassment and uncertainty surrounding the club, several prominent players decided to remain in Turin rather than abandon Juventus during its difficult period.
Among those who stayed were club legends Alessandro Del Piero and Gianluigi Buffon, alongside former Ballon d’Or winner Pavel Nedved and French striker David Trezeguet.
Their loyalty became an important part of Juventus’ recovery, as the club eventually secured promotion back to Serie A after just one season in the second division.
Hamann believes Manchester City could experience a similar situation if they are forced out of the Premier League, although he acknowledges that modern football’s financial demands could complicate matters.
“Obviously, they have to look at their finances if they go down because there might be a transfer embargo. But then again, you’ve got to give them some leeway because obviously they need players.
“I can see a scenario happening where a few players stay, yes. But then again, how do you obey Financial Fair Play because there’ll be players on 100, 200 or 250 grand-a-week and they won’t be playing for anything less in the Championship,” Hamann said.
The former midfielder questioned whether City would be able to maintain their existing wage structure outside the Premier League, particularly if several players continued earning salaries reportedly worth £200,000 or more per week.
He also suggested that the financial regulations of the Premier League and English Football League could place additional pressure on the club to restructure its squad and reduce its wage commitments.
Such a situation could make it difficult for City to convince their biggest stars to remain, especially those who still have ambitions of competing regularly in the Champions League and fighting for major honours.
Meanwhile, a possible relegation could create unexpected opportunities for younger players within the club’s system.
One name attracting attention is teenage American prospect Cavan Sullivan, who is expected to move to England when he turns 18 in the autumn of 2027.
Former United States international Brad Friedel believes a difficult situation for Manchester City could potentially provide the youngster with a quicker route into senior football.
Friedel suggested that playing in the Championship might give Sullivan valuable opportunities to develop and establish himself rather than competing for limited minutes in a star-studded Premier League squad.
He also pointed to Juventus’ experience, explaining that relegation does not necessarily mean every established player will leave or that young talents cannot benefit from the circumstances.
According to Friedel, the situation would only become a genuine concern for individual players once the final sanctions were confirmed and their professional futures were directly affected.
Manchester City’s financial case has developed significantly since the original allegations were brought forward by the Premier League in February 2023.
In September 2026, an independent commission found the club guilty of 114 of the 115 alleged breaches. The findings included serious financial reporting violations and failures to cooperate with the Premier League’s investigation.
City have consistently maintained their innocence and subsequently lodged an appeal against the commission’s findings, arguing that the decision contains significant errors of law, principle and fact.
The sanctions have not yet been determined, with the possibility of a substantial fine, points deduction or other sporting penalties remaining part of the disciplinary process. Relegation or expulsion has also been discussed as a possible severe outcome, although neither has been confirmed.
The case is therefore far from concluded, and the outcome of the appeal and subsequent disciplinary proceedings will determine the club’s next steps.
For now, manager Enzo Maresca and the club’s hierarchy must continue preparing for the future while uncertainty surrounds their long-term position in English football.
If relegation eventually becomes a reality, Manchester City could face one of the biggest squad-building challenges in their modern history.
While some players may choose loyalty over financial incentives and top-flight opportunities, others could view the situation as an opportunity to pursue new challenges elsewhere.
The Juventus example offers City a possible blueprint for survival, but whether their current generation of superstars would demonstrate the same loyalty as Del Piero, Buffon and Nedved remains one of the biggest unanswered questions surrounding the club’s uncertain future.








