David Moyes has been appointed as Everton’s new head coach, tasked with salvaging the club’s challenging season. This marks his return to Everton for a second time, following a successful 12-year tenure with the team. Initially taking charge in 2002, Moyes led the club for over a decade, achieving Champions League qualification and reaching an FA Cup final during his time.
Moyes replaces Sean Dyche as Everton hovers just above the relegation zone. The club hopes that his leadership will spark an improvement in performance, although history indicates that returns to Premier League clubs often face challenges. Notably, five managers have had mixed results in their second spells in the league.
KEVIN KEEGAN (Newcastle)
Kevin Keegan had an unforgettable first spell at Newcastle United, leading them from the second tier to Premier League success. After promotion, Newcastle achieved four consecutive top six finishes, including two runner-up spots in 1995/96 and 1996/97. However, his second term in 2008 ended abruptly due to conflicts with the club’s management.
Harry Redknapp (Portsmouth)
Harry Redknapp faced backlash after leaving Portsmouth for Southampton, branded a ‘Judas’ by fans. He returned to Portsmouth in December 2005, achieving remarkable success, including an FA Cup win in 2008. This marked the club’s first major trophy since 1950, solidifying his legacy at Fratton Park.
Jose Mourinho (Chelsea)
Jose Mourinho delighted Chelsea fans upon his return in 2013, following a successful first stint that included back-to-back Premier League titles. He added another title during his second term but left the club after a decline in results the following season. His impact on Chelsea remains significant in the club’s history.
Roy Hodgson (Crystal Palace)
Roy Hodgson returned to Crystal Palace in 2023, stepping in as the club struggled without a win in 12 games. Previously, he had successfully consolidated the team in the Premier League. Although he helped avoid relegation upon his return, he stepped down the following season amid ongoing struggles.
David Moyes (Everton)
Everton can find inspiration in David Moyes’s successful second term at West Ham. Initially taking over in November 2017, he guided the team to Premier League safety. After a brief absence, he returned in December 2019, leading West Ham to regular European football and winning the 2023 Europa Conference League, marking the club’s first major trophy in 43 years.